The Simpsons: Bart vs the Space Mutants
Sega Genesis
Nostalgia Factor:
About 6 months ago, I reviewed the NES version of this game. You can find that review here. For all its warts, I gave it a decent review score. It ended up getting a B from me. This was probably fueled by nostalgia, as I know the game itself isn't that great. But I just couldn't help but feel charmed by it and all the memories it brought back.
It was when I was doing research for my review that I discovered there was a Genesis port of this game. I hadn't known that before. Right off the bat, I was intrigued. I figured it would be pretty much the same game, but with better graphics, music, and controls. I made it a goal to play it someday.
That's what brings us here. Let's jump in.
Story:
I'm not going to recap the game's story again, as it is literally the exact same story as the NES version of the game, and I'm a lazy bitch. Go read that review if you want the scoop.
Gameplay:
Again, I'm not going to recap how the game works. Go read the NES review.
I will tell you that things haven't changed much from the NES version of the game. Same crappy controls, same gimmicky stage design. In fact, I found this game to be less enjoyable than the NES version for some reason I couldn't quite put my finger on. It's pretty much the exact same game, with small, subtle differences. But I struggled with it.
The controls are not good. You'd think with the Genesis controller, they could have made it easier to run and do long jumps with the extra button on the controller. But they didn't utilize it at all, and you get the same awkward, almost unplayable platform mechanics yet again. But for some unknown, subtle reason (like I said), I found the game to be even more frustrating and difficult. I was dying left and right, and reloading save states like a madman.
I don't know if the gameplay is truly any different, or if I'm just frustrated with it because they had so many opportunities to make this game better with this Genesis port, yet they didn't. I had no fun playing through this game. The whole time I was like "why didn't I just stop with the NES version?" It's almost ruined my enjoyment of the game altogether. Definitely a big mistake playing this one. The plus side is that with save states, you can beat this game in one night. Without them? I shudder to think of it.
Graphics:
I don't know how this is possible, but they somehow managed to make this game look even worse than the NES version. The NES game didn't look great, but you can tell they tried really hard. It had its charm. You'd think with the 16-bit power of the Genesis they could easily top this. But no. It just looks garish and bad.
It's not that the Genesis can't do The Simpsons. I haven't reviewed Virtual Bart or Bart's Nightmare yet (thank god) but I remember them looking much better than this when I was a kid. They looked like how the Simpsons should look in 16-bit. But this is just embarrassing. It's more colorful than the NES game, sure. And I think if you lined up both games side-by-side, a good number of people would say this one looks better. But I just think it's hideous.
Sound:
Where's the Simpsons music? Come on! There is no music from the show to be found in this game. It's all generic (although serviceable) stage music that goes in one ear and out the other. I just finished this game about a week ago and already, if you asked me to identify a track from this game's soundtrack, I wouldn't be able to do it.
Even the NES game had music from the show. I understand there's probably some kind of legal or licensing issue at play here, but this is a grievous mistake.
Overall:
In case you couldn't tell, I didn't enjoy this. I just don't understand how they could have flubbed this port so badly. It wasn't that good of a game to begin with. But they made it worse. Yikes.
I can't recommend this to anyone, even if you are a fan of the NES game. It will result in nothing but disappointment. It can be easily skipped by everyone, unless you're a weirdo like me and let your curiosity get the better of you.
I only give it the "high" grade of a D because at its heart, it is still pretty much identical to the original as far as gameplay. And in these reviews, I'm always harping about how gameplay is the only thing that matters. Not graphics, sound, story, etc. The gameplay. So if it is pretty much the same game, how would I justify the drop from a B to a D- or an F? Even a D is hard to justify, but I can't in good faith give it anything higher than this.
Play it if you must, but this is an easy skip for most gamers. Totally not worth your precious time. I know it wasn't worth mine.
THE GRADE:
D
For a complete index of all my past posts and game reviews, click
>HERE<

.png)









.jpg)
